This post may contain affiliate links.Please read our disclosure policy.For those of us that can’t finish an entire 9-inch pie, enter the loaf pan to make just 5 petite slices! This small Pumpkin Pie in a Loaf Pan is exactly what you need for any small group Thanksgiving day celebrations.

First things first: let’s talk about this CRUST.It’s a cross between a real all-butter pie crust and shortbread.I make it this way because while pie crust is classic, it’s a bit hard to make.

Shortbread is just easier to mix and press into the pan.The flavor of shortbread is slightly better (and sweeter) in my opinion, so I think my hybrid pie curst-shortbread crust is actually superior.Also, the crust is incredibly thick, which prevents any pumpkin custard filling from seeping into it and making it soggy.

My biggest issue with regular pumpkin pie is a soggy crust (IYKYK).If you found me and wish this made a big batch pie, I’ll direct you to my full-size dairy free pumpkin pie made with coconut cream! If you love to make my crustless pumpkin pie for two, you will have some leftover heavy cream.This is the perfect recipe to use it in! The filling in a pumpkin pie is essentially a baked custard because it contains egg and cream, and I really don’t recommend swapping in milk because it will be too thin.

Ingredients Flour.Three-quarters of a cup of all-purpose flour.Fluff it well before scooping it into the measuring cup, and then level it off w

Read More